Five Points Cafe Menu

Welcome to Five Points Cafe, a delightful bar and grill nestled in Sayville, NY. This inviting spot is known for its expansive menu, offering a variety of dishes that cater to all palates. Diners rave about their flavorful Steak Sandwiches and Steak Burgers, which are cooked to perfection. The inventive Spin Chip App and the perfectly crispy French Fries also garner high praise.

For those looking to unwind, Five Points Cafe boasts a diverse drink selection. Their martinis, such as the refreshing CucumberTini and indulgent CoconutTini, are crafted with care. Wine enthusiasts will appreciate the equally curated white wine list, featuring gems from Italy and California.

With friendly, attentive staff and a lively atmosphere, Five Points Cafe transcends the typical dining experience, making it the perfect destination for casual outings or special gatherings. Don’t miss the chance to enjoy their big, fluffy pretzels, a crowd favorite!

White Wines

• Piot Grigio ~ Ballata, Veneto, Italy

  Pale straw color, fresh & fruity with a crisp clean finish.

• Chardonnay ~ Vintage Oaks, California

  Light straw color, aromas of tropical fruit and citrus and pear flavors.

• Sauvignon Blanc ~ Prophecy, New Zealand

  Flavors of grapefruit, lychee and Meyer lemon offer crisp, citrus refreshment.

• Moscato ~ Pellegrino, Sicily, Italy

  Sweet & delicate wine with floral bouquet and fresh peach flavors.

• Rose ~ Juliette, France

  Refreshing and crisp rose wine with layers of lively fruit and a bright, smooth finish.

Red Wines

• Cabernet Sauvignon ~ Robert Hall, California

  Black currant, hints of cedar and spice, full bodied with rich and velvety tannins.

• Malbec ~ Herencia Trabajo, Mendoza, Argentina

  Deep garnet red with aromas and flavors of dark cherry and chocolate, elegant soft tannins.

• Pinot Noir ~ Townhouse, California

  Well-balanced displaying opulent fruit with jammy flavors of boysenberries, raspberries & cherries.

Sangria

• Red Sangria

• White Sangria

On Tap

• Bud Light, USA

  US$5.00

• Stella Artois, Belgium

  US$6.00

• Bluepoint Brewing Toasted Lager, USA

  US$6.00

• Guinness, Ireland

  US$6.00

• IPA

  US$8.00

• Seasonal

  US$7.00

Bottle

• Michelob Ultra, USA

  US$6.00

• Heineken / Heineken Light, Holland

  US$6.00

• Corona / Corona Light, Mexico

  US$6.00

• Miller Lite

  US$6.00

• Non-Alcoholic

  US$6.00

Cocktails

• Downtown Mojito/ Strawberry / Coconut

  Fresh mint and limes muddled with Bacardi rum, simple syrup, club soda

  US$12.00

• Blood Orange Paloma

  Silver tequila, lime juice, simple syrup, fresh blood orange juice, club soda, tajin rim

  US$12.00

• Cherry Grove Punch

  Malibu rum, peach schnapps, triple sec, orange juice, pineapple, grenadine, sprite

  US$11.00

• Rose Lemonade

  Rose wine, lemonade, splash club soda

  US$12.00

• Whiskey Peach Tea

  Jim Beam, peach schnapps, triple sec, sweet tea

  US$12.00

• Limoncello Spritz

  Prosecco, Limoncello, Club Soda, Fresh mint

  US$12.00

• Jalapeno Mule

  Jalapeno infused tequila, lime, ginger beer

  US$11.00

• Downtown Lemonade

  Stoli Razz, Blue curacao & lemonade

  US$12.00

• Jalapeno & Cucumber Margarita

  Spicy tequila, muddled cucumbers, lime juice, triple sec, sour, tajin rim

  US$14.00

• Mango Margarita

  Yave mango tequila, lime, cointreau, sour mix, tajin rim

  US$14.00

Martinis

• Cucumber-Tini

  Crops cucumber vodka, St. Germaine, lemonade

  US$14.00

• Coconut-Tini

  Malibu rum, vanilla vodka, creme de coconut, splash OJ, coconut flakes

  US$14.00

• Blood Orange Tini

  Felene vodka, Cointreau, Lime juice, Fresh Blood Orange juice

  US$14.00

• Watermelon Cosmo

  Watermelon vodka, lime juice, triple sec, splash cranberry

  US$14.00

Margaritas

• Blood Orange Margarita

  US$11.00

• Strawberry Margarita

  US$11.00

• Coconut Margarita

  US$11.00

• Classic Margarita

  US$11.00

Spiked Milkshakes

• Mudslide

  Kahlua, vanilla vodka, irish cream, vanilla ice cream

  US$14.00

• Chocolate Colada

  Silver rum, coco lopez, chocolate ice cream

  US$14.00

• Strawberries & Cream

  Vodka, strawberry puree, irish cream, vanilla ice cream

  US$14.00

• Snickers

  Caramel Vodka, Chocolate Liquor, chocolate ice cream

  US$14.00